Wednesday, September 23, 2015

Reflections on Pastoral Presence


Last year I had experienced what it was like to be in a very deliberate “chaplain” role at my field study with Episcopal Community Services.  And while I have previously written about how powerful and how positive of an experience that was, I found myself also reflecting on how it was also artificial in some ways.  By that I mean, it was at a very particular location, to a very particular population (homeless/mentally ill), for a specified time period, and all under the imprimatur of authority from ECS and to a lesser extent, the church.  It was as if I was a nurse or doctor, walking the halls making my rounds and inserting myself into situations and conversations because of the authority/permission I was given, the job I had to do and the limited time I had to do it in.  After it was over with, I maintained relationships with some of the residents of Uptown Safe Haven and when I would see them again, I noticed how our relationship changed.  It was no longer my “job” to be their chaplain and there was an implicit understanding of that.  It all got me wondering about whether it was possible to experience this same kind of chaplaincy ministry, but in everyday life.  What would it be like to a roving, undercover chaplain of sorts?  Could it be done?  Could I develop intimate, pastoral relationships with total strangers or mere acquaintances, without any ostensible authority or permission other than what might be earned in the moment?  I knew in that moment that while I wanted to work on my pastoral skills this summer, I did not want to do it exclusively confined to the pastoral care office (or any other institution).  I wanted this to be a field study that was at least, in part, in the world. 

As a result, under the supervision of the PCC, I spent part of my time this summer deliberately seeking to put myself in a place (both physically and mentally) where such opportunities might become available, and then to see what happens.  I described it to my supervisor at the PCC as a feeling of being “on call” versus last year where it was more of a feeling of being “on duty.”  Like doctors in our congregation that leap to their feet when there is a parishioner experiencing a medical emergency of some kind, I tried to be daily ‘on alert’ for such moments and to adopt a mentality that I would have a ‘responsibility’ to respond (if at all feasibly possible).  That is, I did my best to commit to not taking ‘a pass’ if it wasn’t convenient or if I wasn’t in the mood, and then to bring those experiences back to the Pastoral Care Center for reflection and discussion.  As I have mentioned in past blogs/reflections, it was remarkable how often the pastoral meetings I had seemed to be tailor made for fleshing out the principles or concepts I was studying.  

So what did I learn? 

First and foremost, developing a mindset of being always potentially ‘on call’ to pastoral moments or needs had an impact it had on me.  I think it was in some ways an important step for me in my development as a priest.  Because of my personality, I am more of a “doer” by nature, and not a natural “feeler.”  My Myers-Briggs profile is ENTJ:  A strategic planner and team organizer; a problem solver.  It doesn’t come as natural to me to be a patient listener, or to be demonstrably empathetic (much less “interpathic”) or to attune in the ways that some of the great pastoral presences do.  I almost certainly suffer from some degree of ADD (if I had enough attention to be tested); my mind easily wanders during stories and I miss critical details.  From my family and upbringing and culture, (as I learned over the course of this summer), I was wired/conditioned to minimize problems when they are shared, to accentuate the positive, challenge people to look on the bright side, and to get back on their feet – there’s people out there with much greater problems after all!  (If it all sounds to me more like a high school basketball coach than a pastor – that’s the way I feel sometimes.) 
And again, don’t get me wrong.  When a parishioner makes an appointment with me or when I was “making my rounds” at last year’s field study, I can do it.  What I am talking about is the rest of the time.  And so this experience was very important in my development because it helped me work on developing a habit/skill to be intentionally pastoral in the unexpected, unplanned moments as well as the just plain regular course of the day.  And over the course of the summer, I came to experience what I already believed to be true;  that such unscheduled “pastoral visits” are around every corner if you are open to them and that each of us have the power to find moments of grace amidst the daily grind.

But they didn’t start out that way.  Many of these encounters began with much more mundane interactions and only led to something more because I had put myself in a mind set to listen for it and to wait for it.  That is, I did not lead any conversations, but rather, listened for hints behind their words that there was a deeper feeling that was trying to be expressed and then to make space for that.  I had my pastoral radar set to max if you will.  Once I heard something or saw something in their body language or in their eyes, it would just take a few empathetic worlds such as, “wow, you must be exhausted having to juggle all of that on top of your job” or “how are you holding up with all of this going on in your life?” to help know I wanted to hear more about what was really on their mind.   It didn’t take a lot.  And to be sure, some of these encounters were helped because of who I was (a seminarian/canon of a Cathedral), but there were many occasions with people who didn’t know any of that, and where our pastoral connection arouse much more out of how I was; my tone of voice, eye contact, openness of body language, physically attuning, and so on. 

And that led to another takeaway which was noticing how many of us carry around feelings of sadness, anger, frustration, stress, confusion, insecurities, and wonderings about where God is in all of this, that are buried just beneath the surface.  It’s a reminder of just how well we have been conditioned to put on our best face; the façade that we have it all under control.  I had such an encounter with a neighbor who is an ex-marine, tough as nails, conservative, square-things-away type of guy as you will ever know.  We were having a chat in the front yard as we will sometimes do and I was filling him in about my comings and goings and their plans for the next trip and so on, until I sensed he had something on his heart.  It turns out that his wife (unbeknownst to me) was having serious medical problems and that he was really at a loss about how to care for her, as well as cook, shop and handle all the chores around the house that she did, plus his own work.  He is a very old-fashioned type of guy who doesn’t know his way around the kitchen to put it mildly.  We ended up talking (or rather he did) for nearly an hour.  At the end, he thanked me for listening in a tender, heartfelt way.  In a tone that I had never heard from him before.  As if it was the first time in a long time that he felt truly listened to.  My first reaction was that his gratitude felt unearned but I have to recognize that is feeling I often have when I actually remember to keep my participation to just listening (instead of going into my default mode and trying to offer advice, minimize, cheer-up or fix).  It never feels in the end like you did anything, but in many cases, it was everything. 
This experience opened my eyes to a way of being pastorally present in everyday, unexpected ways that felt very much like a vocation.  Combined with the training that was happening with the Stephen Ministry, it gave me an idea for how I might incorporate a ministry of intentional, pastoral presence within a church community.

But that is the subject of another blog…


No comments: