Thursday, September 24, 2015

Bringing Church to Work: A Labor Day in the Pulpits homily


Chris Harris, former Canon for Congregational Development, recently moved to St. Bartholomew’s Church in Poway. However, we are still his sponsoring parish as he continues his journey towards the priesthood. Here is his first sermon at St. Bart’s where he brought a little of the Cathedral’s tradition of Labor Day in the Pulpits to Poway, and shared a little of the love and hospitality of our dear friend, Deedra Hardman. He delivered this sermon on his first Sunday at St Bart's, and we like to think Deedra was smiling. 

For those of you I have not yet met, my name is Chris Harris, and I’d like to start by saying thank you for the amazing welcome you have given Joe and me this past week! I am very much looking forward to meeting all of you in the coming months and years as we begin our ministry together. I also want you to know how excited I am to be a part of this community. As a Canon of the Cathedral I had the unique opportunity to travel the country and speak on topics of congregational development in turn gave me the chance to see how different churches are responding to this cultural realignment we are in the midst of; You’ve all heard no doubt about the declining church attendance statistics, the fewer number of Americans identifying as “Christian,” the rise of the spiritual-but-not-religious and so on? Yet despite these undeniable shifts in the culture, I’m continually amazed at how many churches out there are still, for the most part, carrying on as usual; resisting change, hoping I suppose that this will all pass. Fortunately, there are churches, like St. Bart’s and others, who are working to maintain the traditions we cherish and those things that make us uniquely Episcopalian, while embracing change and experimenting with new ways of being church. Churches who will flourish in this post-Christendom 21st century will be those who are willing to try on new ideas, take risks and step outside our comfort zone. Most importantly, they are churches like this one that take seriously the need to answer one of the Bishop’s favorite questions: “What will your church known for?” Put another way, it’s that old question, “If your church were to close its doors tomorrow, would anyone in the community notice? Would our neighbors care?” It’s a way of getting at what impact we are having in building the kingdom out there, that we proclaim each Sunday, in here. 

If all of this sounds like it belongs in a congregational development seminar with little relation to your life, have no fear, because the Bishop’s question is just as important for each of us to ask about our own lives: “What am I known for?” Or put another way, “If I were to stop being a Christian tomorrow, would anyone notice? Would my neighbors care?” (Aside from my car being in the driveway on Sunday mornings that is!) 

As with the church as a whole, it’s a way of asking, what difference am I making in the world in my context? In my community, my family, my neighborhood…and on this Labor Day, in my workplace or in the marketplace? At my prior church, we participated in something called Labor in the Pulpits which was a network of churches, mosques and synagogues which used Labor Day weekend as a chance to lift up the holiness of work and to reflect on how we live out our faith on the job.

This past week, the entire nation has been treated to someone trying to work out their faith in the workplace as a clerk in Kentucky attempts to work out who is saved and who isn’t from the counter of the marriage license dept. Not surprisingly, the result hasn’t been too pretty; with the attendant media circus, angry factions chanting and pointing fingers, debates about hypocrisy and hate, who’s going to hell and who isn’t. Somehow, none of that looks very much like the kingdom of God to me. I don’t see a lot of love being spread, or healing happening. 

The media attention in these moment is particularly sad when you remember that of those 80% of Americans who don’t go to church with any regularity – the very people that churches like ours are trying to reach. Surveys show that those Americans cite two main reasons for why they say away: Christians are too judgmental and too hypocritical. Thanks to our friend in Kentucky, they all have one more reminder as to why they took a pass on Church this morning.

Fortunately, this past week as all of this was playing out, I was reminded of a completely different way of bringing your faith to the workplace. On Thursday, a dear friend of ours died, Deedra Hardmin.  She was one of those people who never met a stranger, who when she talked to you, she made you feel like the only person in the room.  Have you met someone like that? I heard that said several times last week about Bishop Kafity actually. It’s a wonderful gift isn’t it? One that we might all aspire to as it is the gift of presence; a gift that in this busy, over scheduled world of texting and email, can be a real ministry. 

It was that gift of hospitality that made Deedra a natural greeter at her church where she was the first to welcome countless people with open arms and a kiss on the cheek. She always looked for those just on the outside and invited them in, into her church and into her circle of friends, where she made you feel like family. She carried the heart of her church in that way. But what I really loved about her was that she brought that ministry of hospitality to her workplace. At the bank where she worked, she made a point to greet and meet everyone who came through their doors. And once she got to know you, she never failed to wave you into her office to say hello whenever you came by. She’d sit me down, ask how my mom was doing, how’s Joe’s mom, then ask about someone she heard mentioned on the prayer list and how we might help them. There were times her office at the bank felt like coffee hour; no sooner would I get up would she be waving someone else in for a similar hello, but not before introducing us and explaining how we have someone else in common, etc.; People met friends through Deedra.

So persistent was she in her hospitality, I actually worried at times that she’d get in trouble with her boss. I‘d actually try to keep my head down when I came in to make a deposit so she wouldn’t see me, but sure enough, out of the corner of my eye, there was Deedra, waving through her windows, insisting I come back and say hello (I wouldn’t get away THAT easily!). I realized over time, that she wasn’t going to get in trouble. Like her beloved church, she was helping to carry the heart of that bank. Her ministry of welcome and hospitality was helping to create community and a sense of family at the bank just as she did at church.

Over the last week while she was the hospital, that sense of family followed her where she received hundreds of customers, parishioners and friends, intermingling and intermixed, just like her office; a revolving door of friends, family and visitors that made up her extended family. It was a picture of the kingdom of God to me, where all are welcome – NO EXCEPTIONS. 

Unfortunately the quiet faith and small acts of love will rarely make CNN. But they are the very ‘works of faith’ that James refers to in today’s epistle; the small acts of kindness that can make the biggest difference. As we begin to imagine what this church might be known for, why not start with each of us reimagining how we might turn our work places, our neighborhoods, our families, into mission fields to spread the love that we proclaim here each Sunday. This Labor Day, what if we rededicated ourselves to the most important work of our lives and in so doing, help make this world look a little more like the heaven, that the Deedra Hardmans and Bishop Kafitys, and all the saints the have come before them, now call home.




Chris Harris is director of Congregational Development at St. Bartholomew’s Episcopal Church in Poway where he is a candidate for holy orders. His passion is helping people find God in the unexpected areas of life. You can reach him at 619-995-9600 or charris@stbartschurch.org or friend him on Facebook at https://www.facebook.com/chrisharris00

Wednesday, September 23, 2015

The Cross-Cultural Counselor



There were a number of issues raised in The Cross-Cultural Counselor excerpt that perked my interest.  This first was the proposition that, “One who knows only one culture, knows no culture.”  I understood that as essentially saying that until you have experienced other cultures, you really don’t understand that others exist or what it is like to encounter them.  Your world view, in a sense, is akin to the frog under the shell.  You just don’t know what you haven’t seen. 
This truth can have many implications for ministry insofar as it is an opportunity to challenge Christians to understand their fear, and by doing do, help them to rise above it.  I can think of a conversation I had with a gay parishioner who said in response to my mentioning someone who was transgendered, “You know, I just don’t understand those people.  I think they must have something wrong with their head!”  It was helpful to rather than challenge them directly, to reframe their comment in terms of the frog under the shell.  It is the common response to those who are different.  And in fact, many straight people have said that very thing about the person I was talking to – a point that I readily pointed out. 
When we encounter other cultures, our understanding reality is changed.  We now understand that what we thought was reality was merely one, and just one of many, interpretations of reality.  Like a frog under the coconut shell indeed!  How we react to that realization is the key; are we free to move outside of our cultural biases and embrace a new, larger reality, or do we react by withdrawing back to our old assumptions, becoming their defender and champion against the invaders? 

This dynamic plays out not just in cross cultural contexts but also in interpersonal understanding was defined as:  The movement from within oneself to enter the world of another.  Such movements into the world of the other are most often experienced as either sympathy (which is co-suffering through the automatic, unconscious response to the emotional experience of another through the triggering of parallels to one’s own emotional experience) or empathy (an intentional, affective response through actively imagining the emotional experience of another, and attempting to share in it, but recognizing that it is uniquely the other’s – imagining yourself in the other person’s shoes).  The later assumes a share cultural experience and language which allows for the empathic response.  Interpathy is a third form of understanding, that exists when we are able to set aside our own world view, values, and culture language, and to temporarily take on those of another, in order to ‘feel with.’  (p. 29-30)
This sounds to me like the supreme challenge of pastoral care – to be fully present with another; not just shutting off your own distractions and agenda, but your own cultural identity long enough to ‘feel with’ another regardless of such differences.  The other point that resonated with me from this framework, was the idea that one’s ability to enter into interpathy is the key to personal growth:  “All true relational growth comes from our ability to see through another’s eyes, entertaining another’s thoughts, and interpathically sensing another’s feelings.”  It is the means to becoming a more complete as a person because when we “pass over,” that is, enter in to the world of another in that way, we return to our own, and see parts of our life that corresponds to what we saw in the other in new or different ways.  I could see how that process ‘activates’ in us, otherwise dormant aspects of ourselves; becoming more self-aware.  As pointed out in the reading, we return from the journey of friendship a different person; our world view, permanently changed and self-perception altered.  I thank many of us unconsciously know that and is why many of us have a hard time making and maintaining friendships – in our deep heart, we don’t want our world view challenged or changed.  (p.37)

Again, this has massive application to Christian discipleship as we are called to love and serve others and we say that almost blithely and routinely each Sunday, but it is the supreme challenge because it calls us to be willing to have our inner most core, our most fundamental understandings of reality and expectations about life, potentially changed and altered.  Most of us don’t like it when we arrive at church and someone is sitting in “our” pew!  How can we be expected to have our world view changed through intentional, interpathic understanding?  It’s a lot of work and it’s scary.  But I think it’s helpful to understand why.  And more, that the reson behind the resistance to change that holds us back, is in fact the shape of life to which we are truly called.  If we are to take our discipleship seriously, we must be willing to have our realities shaken up on a regular basis.  And to withstand that, we must learn, it seems to me, to hold all things lightly in the first place and live in a way that is always prepared to let go because we never tightened our grip in the first place.

One final reflection on cross-cultural process:  The reading was a reminder to me that our culture informs our interactions with each other in ways we don’t always appreciate.  That’s an important reminder of the importance of the need for multicultural experience and training.  When I took the Visions training (which is one of many excellent multicultural trainings out there), I had my eyes opened to the concept of “target identities” – those different identities we all have, that in our culture, or in other cultures, are valued in different ways and contained power in ways you might take for granted.  For example, as a white, educated male, when I engage with an African-American woman, who did not finish high school, I have a great deal of power and authority in that relationship whether I asked for it or not.  Or culture, for better or worse (and almost always worse, which I will explain later), favors educated over uneducated, white over black, male over female in many contexts in our society so as to make a significant power differential there.  Of course later in that same day, I might encounter a straight, male who is older and taller than me, and I suddenly I might be in my target identity as a gay man, who is not all that tall.  Again, our culture, favors straight over gay, and tall over short.  Again, for better or worse (and the answer is worse).  I might not feel fully empowered to express my opinion or to stand by my opinion in my interactions with this person because I have been conditioned by my culture to know that society is going to favor his/him or me/mine.  Just look at the “ideal” men and women put for by our mass media:  They tend to be articulate (educated), young (we favor youth in our culture), good looking, tall, slender, full head of hair, well dressed (indicated monetary success), and so on.  It struck me that one defense to feeling disempowered is to reminder ourselves that this is only true within our coconut shell.  That is our target identities that disempower us, is not our identity, but the culture’s.  That is, there’s nothing wrong with the frog, it’s the coconut shell that’s screwed up.


Reflections on Pastoral Functions


Ken Callahan wrote in his book, 12 Keys to an Effective Church, that people come to church for one of three reasons (the “three C’s” as he calls them):  They come seeking community, coherence or comfort.  That framework provided me a very helpful framework for understanding the needs of newcomers as I meet them on Sunday mornings.  I find myself doing a bit of an assessment on the spot as I ask them what brought them to the church that day -- which ‘C’ are they here for?  Once you see that people come seeking new friends (community), or a better understanding of life, the world and their purpose in it (coherence) or help through a difficult time such as a death or a break up of a relationship (comfort), I am able to much more effectively hear them, be present with them and help them find their way into our life. 

During a pastoral encounter last week, the readings and discussions on the four pastoral functions (or five or six depending on who you read), came to my mind as I found myself using them in a similar fashion.  As I was preparing for the meeting, I found myself walking through them as a kind of framework for understanding what this person needs from me.  In a way, it stuck me as an extension of the Callahan process; fleshing out what type of “comfort” we need in any given moment.  As set forth by Clebsch, there are four main functions:  Healing, sustaining (which includes consolation), guiding or reconciling (which includes forgiveness). Two more, nurturing which was added by Clinebell, and liberation, which was added by Andrew Lester.

Of course, these are not black and white boundaries between these definitions, nor do people come to us only needing one or two.  But nevertheless, I found it to be tremendously helpful for finding where the person’s energy is at in a conversation as well as helping me to better attune to them and their needs.  In my pastoral meeting last week, the person coming to me had not been in church in a long time.   In fact, he was only meeting with me to talk about the death of his friend Ellen who was a member of the Cathedral.  He was missing his friend, and didn’t know where else to go, so he came to the church where she had so many.  So right off the bat, I assumed he was coming to me seeking consolation and healing in the face of his loss.  However, I found the energy of the conversation moving much more strongly toward questions about faith and purpose – he was really seeking guidance.  (Or ‘coherence’ in the Callahan framework).  Once I realized that, I find myself attuning to him much more effectively and we ended up having a very long, and very meaningful conversation for both of us.  This evolved into a series of pastoral meetings and after four such meetings;  We talked about how he saw God and what he thought of Jesus.  We talked about his fears about organized religion and the many hang-up he had about attending church.  We also spent a lot of time talking about purpose, and how the Gospel can be experienced as a force for liberation rather than obligation, and so on.  


After much ‘warming up’ to me and to Anglican theology (which he found very refreshing and approachable) he got up the courage to attend services on a Sunday --something he had been unwilling to do while his friend was alive.  Afterwards I found myself reflecting that although he had came to me ostensibly to grieve the loss of his friend, he was actually honoring her memory and faith in a way that would have made Ellen smile indeed. 

Jackson Kornfield: Healthy and Unhealthy Desire

Jackson Kornfield’s chapter on Buddhist Psychology’s understanding of desire was a fascinating read as it was a different take on a concept that I struggle with in pastoral encounters with parishioners all the time.  In my position at the Cathedral, I met with many people who wanted to talk to me about their giving.  Often it was in the context of their embarrassment at the notion that they were going to have to reduce their giving – or their pledge – because of some circumstance or another, and it was almost always a difficult conversation.  I of course, did what I often do, and ‘minimized’ the problem – that is, I did my best to make them feel at ease, that it’s OK, that this kind of thing happens, we actually ‘budget’ for it, and so on, and so on.  But while that makes them feel at east – as I have at least removed the possibility of a negative reaction which I suppose they might be most worried about – it doesn’t remove the overriding feeling of failure that I hear in their voice and see in their eyes.  This in turn often leads to a deeper conversation about their life, their work, marriage, etc., which invariably leads to them mentioning something a recent purchase (new car), a vacation they are about to take, or something they recently did, all of which costs money, and invariably renews their sense of embarrassment around the reason they came to me in the first place – their need to reduce their pledge due to a sense of scarcity in their lives.

In classes I teach on the stewardship and giving, I often show a slide summarizing the predicament.  It’s a parishioner emailing me of their need to reduce their pledge due to unforeseen financial circumstances and that they are very sorry and regret very much having to do so.  So far so good.  The fun of the email comes in the sign off, as they mention that they won’t be around the Cathedral for a few months as they are taking a cruise to the Bahamas - -and they cc’d the Dean as well!  I use that email as an example of the disconnect we have between our values and our money and between perceptions of scarcity in the midst of abundance. 

We encounter this disconnect as well when we reject the cultural value that “money buys happiness.”  We intellectually know that it doesn’t of course, but if we scratch the surface of that at all, we discover that in fact when it comes to the basic niceties of life – food, clothing, shelter, health care, etc. – money absolutely does buy happiness!  The problem we have as a culture, is that we are not very good at knowing when to stop. 

Kornfield bring a Buddhist take on the idea by framing it as our misunderstanding of desire.  Its not desire that’s bad, its unhealthy desire that’s the problem.  What’s the difference?  Unhealthy desire leads to suffering, clinging, avarice, fear and possessiveness, while healthy desire leads to happiness, generosity, care integrity and spiritual growth – which in turn leads to a freedom and abundance beyond desire.  Healthy desire brings a sense of “playfulness and ease into the world.”   (p. 188)  That strikes me as a pretty apt description of the ‘abundant’ life that Jesus spoke of, and it seems as the place where enough, becomes enough.  That place in our lives where the necessities of life are taken care of, and we can turn our energies outward.  The struggle that many of our parishioners face is not understanding that distinction, and so they face confusion and guilt – they know something feels ‘off’ about reducing their pledge as they are about to buy a new car – but they don’t have a framework for knowing why or where to draw a line in their own accumulation.  After all, our entire economy and even patriotism in time of war, is centered around consumption.  For Kornfield the key is the 13th principle of Buhhdist psychology:  Don’t try to remove desire from your life, but understand it, be in relationship with it, and find freedom in its midst. 

I think this will be a very helpful approach for talking with people about their relationship with money, with accumulating and with giving, because it frames the discussion in the psychology of abundance, rather than the language of obligation.



Reflections on Pastoral Presence


Last year I had experienced what it was like to be in a very deliberate “chaplain” role at my field study with Episcopal Community Services.  And while I have previously written about how powerful and how positive of an experience that was, I found myself also reflecting on how it was also artificial in some ways.  By that I mean, it was at a very particular location, to a very particular population (homeless/mentally ill), for a specified time period, and all under the imprimatur of authority from ECS and to a lesser extent, the church.  It was as if I was a nurse or doctor, walking the halls making my rounds and inserting myself into situations and conversations because of the authority/permission I was given, the job I had to do and the limited time I had to do it in.  After it was over with, I maintained relationships with some of the residents of Uptown Safe Haven and when I would see them again, I noticed how our relationship changed.  It was no longer my “job” to be their chaplain and there was an implicit understanding of that.  It all got me wondering about whether it was possible to experience this same kind of chaplaincy ministry, but in everyday life.  What would it be like to a roving, undercover chaplain of sorts?  Could it be done?  Could I develop intimate, pastoral relationships with total strangers or mere acquaintances, without any ostensible authority or permission other than what might be earned in the moment?  I knew in that moment that while I wanted to work on my pastoral skills this summer, I did not want to do it exclusively confined to the pastoral care office (or any other institution).  I wanted this to be a field study that was at least, in part, in the world. 

As a result, under the supervision of the PCC, I spent part of my time this summer deliberately seeking to put myself in a place (both physically and mentally) where such opportunities might become available, and then to see what happens.  I described it to my supervisor at the PCC as a feeling of being “on call” versus last year where it was more of a feeling of being “on duty.”  Like doctors in our congregation that leap to their feet when there is a parishioner experiencing a medical emergency of some kind, I tried to be daily ‘on alert’ for such moments and to adopt a mentality that I would have a ‘responsibility’ to respond (if at all feasibly possible).  That is, I did my best to commit to not taking ‘a pass’ if it wasn’t convenient or if I wasn’t in the mood, and then to bring those experiences back to the Pastoral Care Center for reflection and discussion.  As I have mentioned in past blogs/reflections, it was remarkable how often the pastoral meetings I had seemed to be tailor made for fleshing out the principles or concepts I was studying.  

So what did I learn? 

First and foremost, developing a mindset of being always potentially ‘on call’ to pastoral moments or needs had an impact it had on me.  I think it was in some ways an important step for me in my development as a priest.  Because of my personality, I am more of a “doer” by nature, and not a natural “feeler.”  My Myers-Briggs profile is ENTJ:  A strategic planner and team organizer; a problem solver.  It doesn’t come as natural to me to be a patient listener, or to be demonstrably empathetic (much less “interpathic”) or to attune in the ways that some of the great pastoral presences do.  I almost certainly suffer from some degree of ADD (if I had enough attention to be tested); my mind easily wanders during stories and I miss critical details.  From my family and upbringing and culture, (as I learned over the course of this summer), I was wired/conditioned to minimize problems when they are shared, to accentuate the positive, challenge people to look on the bright side, and to get back on their feet – there’s people out there with much greater problems after all!  (If it all sounds to me more like a high school basketball coach than a pastor – that’s the way I feel sometimes.) 
And again, don’t get me wrong.  When a parishioner makes an appointment with me or when I was “making my rounds” at last year’s field study, I can do it.  What I am talking about is the rest of the time.  And so this experience was very important in my development because it helped me work on developing a habit/skill to be intentionally pastoral in the unexpected, unplanned moments as well as the just plain regular course of the day.  And over the course of the summer, I came to experience what I already believed to be true;  that such unscheduled “pastoral visits” are around every corner if you are open to them and that each of us have the power to find moments of grace amidst the daily grind.

But they didn’t start out that way.  Many of these encounters began with much more mundane interactions and only led to something more because I had put myself in a mind set to listen for it and to wait for it.  That is, I did not lead any conversations, but rather, listened for hints behind their words that there was a deeper feeling that was trying to be expressed and then to make space for that.  I had my pastoral radar set to max if you will.  Once I heard something or saw something in their body language or in their eyes, it would just take a few empathetic worlds such as, “wow, you must be exhausted having to juggle all of that on top of your job” or “how are you holding up with all of this going on in your life?” to help know I wanted to hear more about what was really on their mind.   It didn’t take a lot.  And to be sure, some of these encounters were helped because of who I was (a seminarian/canon of a Cathedral), but there were many occasions with people who didn’t know any of that, and where our pastoral connection arouse much more out of how I was; my tone of voice, eye contact, openness of body language, physically attuning, and so on. 

And that led to another takeaway which was noticing how many of us carry around feelings of sadness, anger, frustration, stress, confusion, insecurities, and wonderings about where God is in all of this, that are buried just beneath the surface.  It’s a reminder of just how well we have been conditioned to put on our best face; the façade that we have it all under control.  I had such an encounter with a neighbor who is an ex-marine, tough as nails, conservative, square-things-away type of guy as you will ever know.  We were having a chat in the front yard as we will sometimes do and I was filling him in about my comings and goings and their plans for the next trip and so on, until I sensed he had something on his heart.  It turns out that his wife (unbeknownst to me) was having serious medical problems and that he was really at a loss about how to care for her, as well as cook, shop and handle all the chores around the house that she did, plus his own work.  He is a very old-fashioned type of guy who doesn’t know his way around the kitchen to put it mildly.  We ended up talking (or rather he did) for nearly an hour.  At the end, he thanked me for listening in a tender, heartfelt way.  In a tone that I had never heard from him before.  As if it was the first time in a long time that he felt truly listened to.  My first reaction was that his gratitude felt unearned but I have to recognize that is feeling I often have when I actually remember to keep my participation to just listening (instead of going into my default mode and trying to offer advice, minimize, cheer-up or fix).  It never feels in the end like you did anything, but in many cases, it was everything. 
This experience opened my eyes to a way of being pastorally present in everyday, unexpected ways that felt very much like a vocation.  Combined with the training that was happening with the Stephen Ministry, it gave me an idea for how I might incorporate a ministry of intentional, pastoral presence within a church community.

But that is the subject of another blog…


Re-imagining Pastoral Care – Part 2



III. Opportunities
In part one I outlined where our current model for pastoral care has failed both the church, our members and our communities.  In part two, I will offer some thoughts on how we can begin to shift our pastoral care culture from a clergy-driven model that sees parishioners as primarily care receivers and toward a lay-driven model of forming, inspiring, empowering and sending, care givers.
A.  Integrate Pastoral Care Skills in our Essential Christian Formation
I alluded to our focus on church history, theology, and worship in our formation curriculum in Part One of this paper.  I think the shift in our pastoral care model has to begin with formation.  Why not add a pastoral care skills curriculum to our formation of disciples, just as we do with the formation of clergy?   Stephens Ministry, for example, offers one template for how we might begin offering an in-depth, focused training to not only teach the skills but to change how we see ourselves fundamentally as care givers in the world.  I would also add, that unlike Stephen Ministry, where the focus is on program designed for a small group of uniquely trained lay people, the emphasis here, and the vision that must be cast, is that such training is basic, required training for all who consider themselves Christian.  Whether we call is pastoral skills or Life in Christian Community, we must begin to intentionally train our parishioners in the fundamental skills of active listening, compassion, confidentiality/gossip, vulnerability, triangulation/reconciliation, forgiveness, healing, confession and so on.  If we reserve this for the clergy and select, elite lay people, then we will only perpetuate a culture of pastoral care consumers and fail in our fundamental mission to form and send disciples.
Let’s imagine the case of Brenda who was raised Roman Catholic and where the pastor was the conduit for hospital visits and the like.  Coming to the Episcopal Church as an adult looking to reconnect with her faith journey, she is enrolled in an inquirers class that for the first time, opens her mind to the idea that she is every bit called to be a pastor as the rector is.  Moreover, she is engaged in a class that teachers her how to do that work.  She learns how to be a pastoral presence and through role playing and practice is taught to not only spot opportunities for pastoral encounters, but to actively seek them out because she has come to learn that it is in those moments that we encounter the Holy Spirit.  Brenda would in time see the church not the place for her own care giving when and if in need, but as the training ground for how she learned to begin reimagining her life as a roving pastoral caregiver each day she walks out her door.


B.  A Covenant Community where None are Left Behind
With the foundation of pastoral caregiving as fundamental Christian education in place, we need to also cast a vision for a Christian community where all are valued, known and none are left behind.  Where praying for and caring for the needs of all members is the standard and where newcomers/attenders are offered many doors into relationship.  Such a vision would require intentional in-reach such as periodic pastoral care canvasing to all members (more often than stewardship canvasing for sure!) to uncover those in isolation, small group membership as the fundamental nucleus of Christian Community and an expectation of all members, and the employment of technology for tracking pastoral needs and broadcasting pastoral/personal announcements and actionable connections that goes way beyond a mention in the prayers of the people. 
Too often I am asked, “Is there something going on with Brenda? I thought I heard her name mentioned in the prayers of the people and now that I think about it, I haven’t seen her lately.”  In the clergy-centric model, the clergy is the conduit for all pastoral needs communication often through the official channels of the church such as the prayers of the people which are almost a tease.  (Can you imagine getting an email from your father to pray for your mother’s illness and nothing else?)  Brenda would have made her upcoming surgery known because seeing herself as a care giver, she knows the opportunities and understands the importance of receiving care herself.  Going it alone is not how she understand life in Christian Community.  Brenda’s need for help is then made know through pastoral connections newsletters, prayers would have been solicited, her small group would be responding, the hospital where she is recovering made known, and a “Caring Bridge”[1] set up and linked so parishioners could know exactly what is going on and how Brenda would like them to respond.  The goal being a church community where pastoral care is named as a fundamental value, where vulnerability is celebrated and care-giving understood to be a non-optional responsibility of all members and empowered through relationship and technology. 
C. Lay Administered Pastoral Care Plans are the Norm
Each parishioner experiencing a pastoral need, should have a pastoral care plan developed to guide the community’s response.  While many congregations already do such plans, I would suggest that the structure for developing them is probably untenable if were to be extended to the church I am describing that aspires to care for the other 80%.  This is because most of our pastoral care plans are again, clergy-centric and driven by the needs of “insiders” and so the pool is kept small.  If we were to expand that reach deeply into the community of those formerly “outsiders,” we will likely need to rethink how we structure such plans.  They will need to be lay developed, lay supervised and lay administered.  Clergy, will need to step back from their roles as care givers, and become mentors and coaches for lay care givers. 
In the example of Brenda.  When she made her surgery known to the church, a member, possibly a member of her small group ideally, would be the point person for developing a pastoral care plan (including being the go to person for questions, setting up a visit schedule and needs list through a “caring bridge” and so on).  This would continue after her return from the hospital and a long-term plan is put into place depending on her needs.  Ride sharing, occasional clergy check-ins, meals, monitoring of her progress and so on would be administered through her point person empowered through technology.  If Brenda isn’t part of a small group or if she is not getting the kind of ongoing support needed, the point person would assign a Stephen Minister (or similar) to be with Brenda during the ensuing months – perhaps becoming that point person for additional care giving if needed.    
D. Clergy Role Shifts to Teacher/Mentor
So what is the role then for clergy in this model?  As I alluded to above, it needs to shift to the roles of teacher, mentor and administrator of lay care givers and away from the role of primary care provider.  In Part One of this essay, I mentioned that I think of the church as a “Discipleship Academy” that is, we should see ourselves as a seminary that actively graduates followers of Christ into the world to love and serve it and in the process, make more disciples.  As such, our academy needs teachers and mentors who gauge success not on the number of people they visited, but by the number of care givers they graduated and the number of people they have visited.      
E.  Extending Pastoral Care to the Neighborhood
Finally, if the scorecard for clergy needs to shift from caring for parishioners to forming care givers, we need to create a scorecord for this new army of pastoral care providers.  I would propose here that a page be taken from the missional church and that along with the training in pastoral care, we cast a vision for our membership to begin seeing their neighborhood, the very block on which they live, as their mission field and their home as the mission center.  Just as the church as a pastoral care plan for its members, might our members have a pastoral care plan for their neighbors?  Just as we might use technology to develop and empower networks of parishioners with needs might we do that on our own block?  I have experienced this in our own neighborhood where we have mobilized neighbors to pull together to care for one of our own.  We have developed with some a tool and garden equipment borrowing network and ‘open door’ policies with our sheds so I can borrow a hedge trimmer or lawn mower when we need it and none of us has to own all of it.  Could a neighborhood prayer list be far behind? 
Of course, such relationship don’t start there.  We had to build up to it beginning with breaking the ice over dinner invitations, then joint parties, joint garage sales and so on.  If we are to be kingdom builders, we need to start with being community makers in our own backyards and extending pastoral care is an important part of that.  In time, we might even begin to think of our small groups less as church groups and more as neighborhood groups. 
IV.  Conclusion
While not a comprehensive solution, this essay seeks to inspire our imagination about how we might reimagine the how and why of pastoral care and its possible role in the larger emerging church conversation in which we are engaged.  An important component of this, which is implied, is that any congregation seeking such a culture shift, would also have to implement as systematic theology of gift discernment and the ministry of all believers.  While it is a concept we certainly talk about and aspire to, we undermine it as soon as we step into church where the priest is responsible for the exclusive production and execution of 90% of what goes on, including writing and even delivering the “prayers of the people.”  If praying shapes believing, then worship forms our discipleship.  Just as we must continue to reform and open up our worship, that spirit must extend to the sacred cow of pastoral care.  By empowering our membership with the full compliment of the skills and aspirations of a disciple, we will begin to shift the culture from a customer/member mentality to a missionary mind.  And only then, will we begin to unlock the promise of the missional church within us.  



[1] Websites such as http://www.caringbridge.org, if employed and deployed to the congregation in systematics ways, have the capacity to revolutionize pastoral care and community connection.  Private Facebook groups are also a possibly opportunity that is underutilized – particularly for smaller congregations – as social media adoption continues to grow. 

Re-imagining Pastoral Care – Part 1


I.  Introduction
My experiences this summer both in and outside the Pastoral Counseling Center, as well as my exposure to the Stephen Ministry training and all the materials we have studied throughout (particularly the four pastoral functions), has inspired me to begin re-thinking how we do pastoral care in our congregations.  In fact, I find myself wondering whether it is time for us as a church to re-imagine our approach to pastoral care all together.  My experience over the summer has me increasingly convinced that the current model, which I can only describe as a clergy-centric model, particularly as it plays out in larger congregations, has been, save for a small percentage of well-connected, insiders, a failure.  In this two-part reflection, I will offer some points of departure from our current model and some thoughts for further development, which I hope will contribute to the emergence of a new, lay-driven model for pastoral care and perhaps over time, a shift in the culture of how we care for each other and our collective self-perception as disciples.  
Why this emphasis on pastoral care as the epicenter for change in the church? 
In my view, there has been much written about the need to shift our thinking about church in this post-denominational, post-modern world.  Most of that work has focused on opportunities mission and evangelism through the emerging and fresh expressions of church -- outreach.  But none as far as I have seen, have extended this realignment to pastoral care -- in reach.  In my view, in our anxiety about declining attendance, we have put the cart before the horse once again.  If we cannot create the loving, compassionate communities within our “discipleship academies” (my understanding of church), then our witness to a world starved for authenticity and meaning, will be seen for the hallow, repackaging of the church they have already rejected or never entered in the first place.
This paper will be constitute not so much a first draft, but rather points for discussion about what’s not working and how we might reorganize and reorient our churches around pastoral care in a way would be transformative for our congregations, the lives of our members and the greater community.  In Part 1 I will focus on what needs to change and in Part 2, I will cast a vision for a law-driven model and consider its possible implications for the missional church. 
II. Problems with the current model
The problems I see with the current clergy-driven model[1] for pastoral care which I have experienced, are four-fold: 
(1) We do not reach the vast majority of our parishioners in need. 
In the context of a larger church at least, I have seen over and over, that it is the “insiders” that receive the vast majority of pastoral care.  Who are the “insiders”?  I would define them as those parishioners who are currently[2] involved, well-connected or are considered major donors (though even that is not necessarily a guarantee of insider status).  Insiders tend to enjoy a personal relationship with the clergy, work with the clergy in leadership or ministry, and/or are otherwise known by other insiders such as assistant clergy, staff, vestry or key lay leaders.  They are well enough connected such at any prolonged absence would be noticed and a phone call would be placed (although one does not necessarily always follow the other), or that a pastoral need shared with other parishioners, could be expected to eventually reach the ears of the clergy.  I would guess, and this is only a guess, that we are talking about 20% or so of the congregation (if my instincts around the 80-20 principle play out here as they so often do elsewhere in the church).  Perhaps if a little less or perhaps a bit more, bit either way if you are in the 90 or even 70% of the congregation, your pastoral needs largely go unnoticed and, unless you reach out and ask for help, likely to go unmet.  
And for the record, I am completely sympathetic to the response by clergy at larger churches that it is just unrealistic for to track everyone from the altar.  No question that is true.  But that doesn’t change the impact that follows when a long time member has been absent for 3 months without a phone call from the rector.  It is up to us to change the way we do pastoral care because our expectation that people will call if needed is just not realistic.[3]  Why is a simple phone call too much to ask?  Because (a) many people who are outsiders, actually think of themselves as insiders (and thus they don’t think they should have to ask – after all, they were the person that led the campaign to restore the Great Hall back in the day, or whatever); and (2) the other population of outsiders by definition, sadly, doesn’t feel sufficiently connected, despite regular attendance and/or giving, to even ask.[4]  As hard as it is to believe to us insiders, the majority of our parishioners do not think to be put on the prayers of the people or to request that someone bring communion for them while they are in the hospital.  They just don’t have a deep enough of a relationship for it to occur to them.  Others have either too low of an expectation/understanding of the variety of pastoral responses (beyond anointing and communion) or they assume that since we have so few clergy, that such things should really be reserved for “truly” sick or dying.[5] 
(2) We have no idea how to offer long-term pastoral care.
Unless we have begun a Stephen Ministry-type program or have access to something like the Pastoral Counseling Center, we have few options for those whose pastoral needs extend beyond the 3 or 4 visits that are allowed for clergy.   And while I fully appreciate and agree with the Bishop’s guidelines in such circumstances, and also appreciate the distinction between pastoral care and pastoral counseling, the truth is, there is a need for pastoral care for people facing long term illness or loss.  We tend to be much better at responding to the pastoral needs when they are in the emergency stage and often can overwhelm a parishioner with visits and casseroles, but contending with the loss that attends the death of a spouse for example, takes years to heal.  After the flowers, the communion, the lasagnas and the beautiful memorial service, many parishioners feel abandoned during the period of time when their loss will be felt the most; the ensuing months and years and holidays alone that will inevitably follow.  Again, I have seen long time parishioners fall into isolation after the death of a loved one while we have all moved on to descend like the Normandy invasion on the next insider who has been hit with some kind of trauma or grief.[6]  While many of our congregations offer grief groups and host other community support groups with which we can connect parishioners, but they are often very niche oriented or wholly secular in nature.      
(3) Pastoral care is not part of our Christian Formation.
Because we see pastoral care as a discipline largely reserved for the clergy, it doesn’t occur to us that learning the skills of pastoral care is every bit as important (if not more so) than learning the about the history of the Christianity, the Reformation or theology.  And because we don’t teach, inspire and empower our parishioners to care for one another, they are stuck in a mindset that sees themselves primarily as a care receiver rather than as potential care-giver. This thinking only perpetuates a customer/consumer mindset rather than a discipleship mindset amongst our membership.  While it ensures that clergy feel needed and appreciated[7], it reinforces the notion of pastoral care as a kind of perk of membership, rather than a responsibility and a ministry to which we are all called.  The solution which I will focus on in the next paper is to turn us all into care givers first and foremost.  To teach us that pastoral care is not a program or a special skill reserved for clergy, but the responsibility and blessing that we can and must all share in.  I would predict, that if we can move the needle on this score, we would see in increase in our “outsiders” asking for pastoral care when they need it.  For starters, they would no longer see themselves as outsiders, and secondly, because they have been empowered to be givers first, they will be more comfortable, more conditioned and more permissioned, with asking to receive.[8]
(4) The current model has no impact on our surrounding neighborhoods or community. 
While I criticized the missional church movement as being too outreach-focused in my opening, I think the converse it true with respect to our current thinking about pastoral care – it is regarded entirely as in-reach.   The missional church thinkers are correct, in our post-Christendom world, we must reorient our understanding of church to take place not in buildings and behind stain glass windows, but in the neighborhoods (where God is already at work by the way if we would only pay attention).  But we must in essence look for ways to turn all or a part of everything we do “inside out.”[9]  To this movement, I would humbly like to add the area of pastoral care to the emerging prescription for reforming our institutional churches into missional churches.  There is probably no single evangelistic opportunity more powerful and transformative (for us as much as them), than extending pastoral care to our friends, our neighbors and strangers in natural, authentic, relationally driven ways.[10]  By shifting our understanding of pastoral care and inspiring our parishioners to see themselves fundamentally as care-givers, we can become missionaries to our neighborhoods which is the only evangelism that works. 
Again, while there are many congregations who will open their doors for candle light vigils or prayer services in moments of community tragedy or in response to current events, and I applaud those moments, but they are at the end of the day, only moments.  They make us feel good because they make for great visuals on the evening news and we love to see “interfaith” moments packing our churches, there is little way to follow-up or follow-through with the relationships that are begun in those moments.[11]  In that way, they are really no more evangelistic than a funeral or a wedding where our commitment to the purpose of the gathering outweighs our ability to capture names and response information necessary to actively invite the curious into relationship.  In short, the most effusive welcome to return next Sunday during the announcements just doesn’t cut is for the vast majority who are unchurched for reasons that are too deep to be so overcome so easily.[12]  The type of pastoral outreach I am advocating is one-on-one and deeply and authentically relational. 

Continued in part II.




[1] Of course if this were to be developed into an essay, I would spend some time defining that I mean by the current clergy-centric model and perhaps even describe how it plays out in the various sized congregations (family, pastoral, program and so on).  For purposes of these two reflections however, I will leave it to the reader use and apply these ideas to their own context and evaluate them in that light.  As with all generalizations, there are exceptions as well as distinctions in different contexts, and victories as well, and I am also the first to acknowledge the dangers of universalizing one’s experiences and/or anecdotal testimonies from other contexts.  So if you find yourself rejecting the notion outright that our current model is clergy-centric, I would invite the reader’s responses either in the comments of wherever this is published or to my email at chrisharris00@gmail.com. 
[2] Notice I say currently.  I have seen again and again, for even those who were once well connected, former vestry, former wardens, and so on, can fall off the pastoral radar.  Particularly older members who might have been at one time “pillars of the community” but who have stepped back from their institutional involvement due to declining health or to make room for others, can be forgotten in favor of their younger, more engaged (and therefore more visible) counterparts.
[3] In fact, and this might be considered somewhat controversial, but I would go so far as to allege that it is the dirty little secret of the clergy-centric model:  We don’t want them to all call!  If they did, we would be completely overwhelmed and have no time for the other parts of our ministry that feed us. 
[4] I think it bears noting that by their nature, and as I have reflected in the past, most people are not inclined to reach out in times of need.  We want to see ourselves as being in control and immortal.  Others see the church as a place you go and interact with when you are at your best.  That is, you go to church when you have your s**t together. How
[5] In my experience this summer talking with outsiders about pastoral care (meaning, church attenders), I found myself ending the encounter with asking if they would like a visit from clergy or someone to bring them communion?  The response was more often than not, “oh no, that’s OK.  It’s not that big a deal…” 
[6] Look no further than the number of our parishioners who end up leaving estate gifts to their hospice provider rather than their church.
[7] Dirty little secret number two for those counting.
[8] See Influence by Dr. Robert Cialdini for a summary of the power of reciprocity as one of the most power influencers of human behavior. http://www.amazon.com/Influence-Psychology-Persuasion-Revised-Edition/dp/006124189X
[9] I offer a teaching for churches called “Inside Out” if you would like to explore what I mean by this more fully with your congregation.  How can we re-cast every aspect of our bulletin to be at least in part, to be an outreach opportunity?  The answers may surprise and inspire you!
[10] This is the fundamental lesson of pastoral care/evangelism opportunities like “Ashes to Go.”  While decidedly not “natural” or organically arising from relationship (let’s face it, it is something of a costumed stunt to the outside world), it is nevertheless a safe, field study of sorts for our congregations in street side pastoral care.  If your congregation is not doing it you need to start.  And if your congregation see it as an act reserved for the clergy only, you need to change that thinking.  Stay in your churches and hand Ashes to Go over to your lay people.  These kinds of events are as much as about evangelizing ourselves as it is the community but clergy need to get out of the way for that to happen. 
[11] This would qualify as dirty little secret number three but so few churches actually open their doors this way, it doesn’t technically qualify.
[12] Dirty little secret number four or self-deluding evangelism myth number one depending on your personal preference.