I.
Introduction
My
experiences this summer both in and outside the Pastoral Counseling Center, as
well as my exposure to the Stephen Ministry training and all the materials we
have studied throughout (particularly the four pastoral functions), has inspired
me to begin re-thinking how we do pastoral care in our congregations. In fact, I find myself wondering whether it
is time for us as a church to re-imagine our approach to pastoral care all
together. My experience over the summer has
me increasingly convinced that the current model, which I can only describe as
a clergy-centric model, particularly as it plays out in larger congregations, has
been, save for a small percentage of well-connected, insiders, a failure. In this two-part reflection, I will offer
some points of departure from our current model and some thoughts for further
development, which I hope will contribute to the emergence of a new, lay-driven
model for pastoral care and perhaps over time, a shift in the culture of how we
care for each other and our collective self-perception as disciples.
Why this
emphasis on pastoral care as the epicenter for change in the church?
In my view,
there has been much written about the need to shift our thinking about church
in this post-denominational, post-modern world.
Most of that work has focused on opportunities mission and evangelism
through the emerging and fresh expressions of church -- outreach. But none as far as I have seen, have extended
this realignment to pastoral care -- in reach.
In my view, in our anxiety about declining attendance, we have put the
cart before the horse once again. If we
cannot create the loving, compassionate communities within our “discipleship academies”
(my understanding of church), then our witness to a world starved for
authenticity and meaning, will be seen for the hallow, repackaging of the
church they have already rejected or never entered in the first place.
This paper
will be constitute not so much a first draft, but rather points for discussion about
what’s not working and how we might reorganize and reorient our churches around
pastoral care in a way would be transformative for our congregations, the lives
of our members and the greater community.
In Part 1 I will focus on what needs to change and in Part 2, I will
cast a vision for a law-driven model and consider its possible implications for
the missional church.
II. Problems with the current model
The problems
I see with the current clergy-driven model[1]
for pastoral care which I have experienced, are four-fold:
(1) We do
not reach the vast majority of our parishioners in need.
In the
context of a larger church at least, I have seen over and over, that it is the
“insiders” that receive the vast majority of pastoral care. Who are the “insiders”? I would define them as those parishioners who
are currently[2]
involved, well-connected or are considered major donors (though even that is
not necessarily a guarantee of insider status).
Insiders tend to enjoy a personal relationship with the clergy, work
with the clergy in leadership or ministry, and/or are otherwise known by other
insiders such as assistant clergy, staff, vestry or key lay leaders. They are well enough connected such at any
prolonged absence would be noticed and a phone call would be placed (although
one does not necessarily always follow the other), or that a pastoral need
shared with other parishioners, could be expected to eventually reach the ears
of the clergy. I would guess, and this
is only a guess, that we are talking about 20% or so of the congregation (if my
instincts around the 80-20 principle play out here as they so often do
elsewhere in the church). Perhaps if a
little less or perhaps a bit more, bit either way if you are in the 90 or even
70% of the congregation, your pastoral needs largely go unnoticed and, unless
you reach out and ask for help, likely to go unmet.
And for the
record, I am completely sympathetic to the response by clergy at larger
churches that it is just unrealistic for to track everyone from the altar. No question that is true. But that doesn’t change the impact that
follows when a long time member has been absent for 3 months without a phone
call from the rector. It is up to us to
change the way we do pastoral care because our expectation that people will
call if needed is just not realistic.[3] Why is a simple phone call too much to
ask? Because (a) many people who are
outsiders, actually think of themselves as insiders (and thus they don’t think they
should have to ask – after all, they were the person that led the campaign to
restore the Great Hall back in the day, or whatever); and (2) the other
population of outsiders by definition, sadly, doesn’t feel sufficiently
connected, despite regular attendance and/or giving, to even ask.[4] As hard as it is to believe to us insiders,
the majority of our parishioners do not think to be put on the prayers of the
people or to request that someone bring communion for them while they are in
the hospital. They just don’t have a
deep enough of a relationship for it to occur to them. Others have either too low of an
expectation/understanding of the variety of pastoral responses (beyond
anointing and communion) or they assume that since we have so few clergy, that
such things should really be reserved for “truly” sick or dying.[5]
(2) We
have no idea how to offer long-term pastoral care.
Unless we
have begun a Stephen Ministry-type program or have access to something like the
Pastoral Counseling Center, we have few options for those whose pastoral needs
extend beyond the 3 or 4 visits that are allowed for clergy. And while I fully appreciate and agree with
the Bishop’s guidelines in such circumstances, and also appreciate the
distinction between pastoral care and pastoral counseling, the truth is, there
is a need for pastoral care for people facing long term illness or loss. We tend to be much better at responding to
the pastoral needs when they are in the emergency stage and often can overwhelm
a parishioner with visits and casseroles, but contending with the loss that
attends the death of a spouse for example, takes years to heal. After the flowers, the communion, the lasagnas
and the beautiful memorial service, many parishioners feel abandoned during the
period of time when their loss will be felt the most; the ensuing months and
years and holidays alone that will inevitably follow. Again, I have seen long time parishioners
fall into isolation after the death of a loved one while we have all moved on
to descend like the Normandy invasion on the next insider who has been hit with
some kind of trauma or grief.[6] While many of our congregations offer grief
groups and host other community support groups with which we can connect
parishioners, but they are often very niche oriented or wholly secular in
nature.
(3) Pastoral
care is not part of our Christian Formation.
Because we
see pastoral care as a discipline largely reserved for the clergy, it doesn’t
occur to us that learning the skills of pastoral care is every bit as important
(if not more so) than learning the about the history of the Christianity, the
Reformation or theology. And because we
don’t teach, inspire and empower our parishioners to care for one another, they
are stuck in a mindset that sees themselves primarily as a care receiver rather than as potential care-giver. This thinking only perpetuates a
customer/consumer mindset rather than a discipleship mindset amongst our
membership. While it ensures that clergy
feel needed and appreciated[7],
it reinforces the notion of pastoral care as a kind of perk of membership,
rather than a responsibility and a ministry to which we are all called. The solution which I will focus on in the
next paper is to turn us all into care givers first and foremost. To teach us that pastoral care is not a
program or a special skill reserved for clergy, but the responsibility and
blessing that we can and must all share in.
I would predict, that if we can move the needle on this score, we would
see in increase in our “outsiders” asking for pastoral care when they need
it. For starters, they would no longer
see themselves as outsiders, and secondly, because they have been empowered to
be givers first, they will be more comfortable, more conditioned and more
permissioned, with asking to receive.[8]
(4) The
current model has no impact on our surrounding neighborhoods or community.
While I
criticized the missional church movement as being too outreach-focused in my
opening, I think the converse it true with respect to our current thinking
about pastoral care – it is regarded entirely as in-reach. The missional church thinkers are correct, in
our post-Christendom world, we must reorient our understanding of church to
take place not in buildings and behind stain glass windows, but in the
neighborhoods (where God is already at work by the way if we would only pay
attention). But we must in essence look
for ways to turn all or a part of everything we do “inside out.”[9] To this movement, I would humbly like to add
the area of pastoral care to the emerging prescription for reforming our
institutional churches into missional churches.
There is probably no single evangelistic opportunity more powerful and
transformative (for us as much as them), than extending pastoral care to our
friends, our neighbors and strangers in natural, authentic, relationally driven
ways.[10] By shifting our understanding of pastoral
care and inspiring our parishioners to see themselves fundamentally as
care-givers, we can become missionaries to our neighborhoods which is the only
evangelism that works.
Again, while
there are many congregations who will open their doors for candle light vigils
or prayer services in moments of community tragedy or in response to current
events, and I applaud those moments, but they are at the end of the day, only moments. They make us feel good because they make for
great visuals on the evening news and we love to see “interfaith” moments
packing our churches, there is little way to follow-up or follow-through with
the relationships that are begun in those moments.[11] In that way, they are really no more
evangelistic than a funeral or a wedding where our commitment to the purpose of
the gathering outweighs our ability to capture names and response information
necessary to actively invite the curious into relationship. In short, the most effusive welcome to return
next Sunday during the announcements just doesn’t cut is for the vast majority
who are unchurched for reasons that are too deep to be so overcome so easily.[12] The type of pastoral outreach I am advocating
is one-on-one and deeply and authentically relational.
Continued in
part II.
[1] Of
course if this were to be developed into an essay, I would spend some time
defining that I mean by the current clergy-centric model and perhaps even
describe how it plays out in the various sized congregations (family, pastoral,
program and so on). For purposes of
these two reflections however, I will leave it to the reader use and apply
these ideas to their own context and evaluate them in that light. As with all generalizations, there are
exceptions as well as distinctions in different contexts, and victories as
well, and I am also the first to acknowledge the dangers of universalizing
one’s experiences and/or anecdotal testimonies from other contexts. So if you find yourself rejecting the notion
outright that our current model is clergy-centric, I would invite the reader’s
responses either in the comments of wherever this is published or to my email
at chrisharris00@gmail.com.
[2]
Notice I say currently. I have seen
again and again, for even those who were once well connected, former vestry,
former wardens, and so on, can fall off the pastoral radar. Particularly older members who might have
been at one time “pillars of the community” but who have stepped back from
their institutional involvement due to declining health or to make room for
others, can be forgotten in favor of their younger, more engaged (and therefore
more visible) counterparts.
[3] In
fact, and this might be considered somewhat controversial, but I would go so
far as to allege that it is the dirty little secret of the clergy-centric
model: We don’t want them to all
call! If they did, we would be
completely overwhelmed and have no time for the other parts of our ministry
that feed us.
[4] I
think it bears noting that by their nature, and as I have reflected in the
past, most people are not inclined to reach out in times of need. We want to see ourselves as being in control
and immortal. Others see the church as a
place you go and interact with when you are at your best. That is, you go to church when you have your
s**t together. How
[5] In
my experience this summer talking with outsiders about pastoral care (meaning,
church attenders), I found myself ending the encounter with asking if they
would like a visit from clergy or someone to bring them communion? The response was more often than not, “oh no,
that’s OK. It’s not that big a
deal…”
[6]
Look no further than the number of our parishioners who end up leaving estate
gifts to their hospice provider rather than their church.
[7]
Dirty little secret number two for those counting.
[8]
See Influence by Dr. Robert Cialdini
for a summary of the power of reciprocity as one of the most power influencers
of human behavior. http://www.amazon.com/Influence-Psychology-Persuasion-Revised-Edition/dp/006124189X
[9] I
offer a teaching for churches called “Inside Out” if you would like to explore
what I mean by this more fully with your congregation. How can we re-cast every aspect of our
bulletin to be at least in part, to be an outreach opportunity? The answers may surprise and inspire you!
[10]
This is the fundamental lesson of pastoral care/evangelism opportunities like
“Ashes to Go.” While decidedly not
“natural” or organically arising from relationship (let’s face it, it is
something of a costumed stunt to the outside world), it is nevertheless a safe,
field study of sorts for our congregations in street side pastoral care. If your congregation is not doing it you need
to start. And if your congregation see
it as an act reserved for the clergy only, you need to change that
thinking. Stay in your churches and hand
Ashes to Go over to your lay
people. These kinds of events are as
much as about evangelizing ourselves as it is the community but clergy need to
get out of the way for that to happen.
[11]
This would qualify as dirty little secret number three but so few churches
actually open their doors this way, it doesn’t technically qualify.
[12]
Dirty little secret number four or self-deluding evangelism myth number one
depending on your personal preference.

No comments:
Post a Comment