Wednesday, September 23, 2015

Jackson Kornfield: Healthy and Unhealthy Desire

Jackson Kornfield’s chapter on Buddhist Psychology’s understanding of desire was a fascinating read as it was a different take on a concept that I struggle with in pastoral encounters with parishioners all the time.  In my position at the Cathedral, I met with many people who wanted to talk to me about their giving.  Often it was in the context of their embarrassment at the notion that they were going to have to reduce their giving – or their pledge – because of some circumstance or another, and it was almost always a difficult conversation.  I of course, did what I often do, and ‘minimized’ the problem – that is, I did my best to make them feel at ease, that it’s OK, that this kind of thing happens, we actually ‘budget’ for it, and so on, and so on.  But while that makes them feel at east – as I have at least removed the possibility of a negative reaction which I suppose they might be most worried about – it doesn’t remove the overriding feeling of failure that I hear in their voice and see in their eyes.  This in turn often leads to a deeper conversation about their life, their work, marriage, etc., which invariably leads to them mentioning something a recent purchase (new car), a vacation they are about to take, or something they recently did, all of which costs money, and invariably renews their sense of embarrassment around the reason they came to me in the first place – their need to reduce their pledge due to a sense of scarcity in their lives.

In classes I teach on the stewardship and giving, I often show a slide summarizing the predicament.  It’s a parishioner emailing me of their need to reduce their pledge due to unforeseen financial circumstances and that they are very sorry and regret very much having to do so.  So far so good.  The fun of the email comes in the sign off, as they mention that they won’t be around the Cathedral for a few months as they are taking a cruise to the Bahamas - -and they cc’d the Dean as well!  I use that email as an example of the disconnect we have between our values and our money and between perceptions of scarcity in the midst of abundance. 

We encounter this disconnect as well when we reject the cultural value that “money buys happiness.”  We intellectually know that it doesn’t of course, but if we scratch the surface of that at all, we discover that in fact when it comes to the basic niceties of life – food, clothing, shelter, health care, etc. – money absolutely does buy happiness!  The problem we have as a culture, is that we are not very good at knowing when to stop. 

Kornfield bring a Buddhist take on the idea by framing it as our misunderstanding of desire.  Its not desire that’s bad, its unhealthy desire that’s the problem.  What’s the difference?  Unhealthy desire leads to suffering, clinging, avarice, fear and possessiveness, while healthy desire leads to happiness, generosity, care integrity and spiritual growth – which in turn leads to a freedom and abundance beyond desire.  Healthy desire brings a sense of “playfulness and ease into the world.”   (p. 188)  That strikes me as a pretty apt description of the ‘abundant’ life that Jesus spoke of, and it seems as the place where enough, becomes enough.  That place in our lives where the necessities of life are taken care of, and we can turn our energies outward.  The struggle that many of our parishioners face is not understanding that distinction, and so they face confusion and guilt – they know something feels ‘off’ about reducing their pledge as they are about to buy a new car – but they don’t have a framework for knowing why or where to draw a line in their own accumulation.  After all, our entire economy and even patriotism in time of war, is centered around consumption.  For Kornfield the key is the 13th principle of Buhhdist psychology:  Don’t try to remove desire from your life, but understand it, be in relationship with it, and find freedom in its midst. 

I think this will be a very helpful approach for talking with people about their relationship with money, with accumulating and with giving, because it frames the discussion in the psychology of abundance, rather than the language of obligation.



No comments: