Wednesday, September 23, 2015

Re-imagining Pastoral Care – Part 2



III. Opportunities
In part one I outlined where our current model for pastoral care has failed both the church, our members and our communities.  In part two, I will offer some thoughts on how we can begin to shift our pastoral care culture from a clergy-driven model that sees parishioners as primarily care receivers and toward a lay-driven model of forming, inspiring, empowering and sending, care givers.
A.  Integrate Pastoral Care Skills in our Essential Christian Formation
I alluded to our focus on church history, theology, and worship in our formation curriculum in Part One of this paper.  I think the shift in our pastoral care model has to begin with formation.  Why not add a pastoral care skills curriculum to our formation of disciples, just as we do with the formation of clergy?   Stephens Ministry, for example, offers one template for how we might begin offering an in-depth, focused training to not only teach the skills but to change how we see ourselves fundamentally as care givers in the world.  I would also add, that unlike Stephen Ministry, where the focus is on program designed for a small group of uniquely trained lay people, the emphasis here, and the vision that must be cast, is that such training is basic, required training for all who consider themselves Christian.  Whether we call is pastoral skills or Life in Christian Community, we must begin to intentionally train our parishioners in the fundamental skills of active listening, compassion, confidentiality/gossip, vulnerability, triangulation/reconciliation, forgiveness, healing, confession and so on.  If we reserve this for the clergy and select, elite lay people, then we will only perpetuate a culture of pastoral care consumers and fail in our fundamental mission to form and send disciples.
Let’s imagine the case of Brenda who was raised Roman Catholic and where the pastor was the conduit for hospital visits and the like.  Coming to the Episcopal Church as an adult looking to reconnect with her faith journey, she is enrolled in an inquirers class that for the first time, opens her mind to the idea that she is every bit called to be a pastor as the rector is.  Moreover, she is engaged in a class that teachers her how to do that work.  She learns how to be a pastoral presence and through role playing and practice is taught to not only spot opportunities for pastoral encounters, but to actively seek them out because she has come to learn that it is in those moments that we encounter the Holy Spirit.  Brenda would in time see the church not the place for her own care giving when and if in need, but as the training ground for how she learned to begin reimagining her life as a roving pastoral caregiver each day she walks out her door.


B.  A Covenant Community where None are Left Behind
With the foundation of pastoral caregiving as fundamental Christian education in place, we need to also cast a vision for a Christian community where all are valued, known and none are left behind.  Where praying for and caring for the needs of all members is the standard and where newcomers/attenders are offered many doors into relationship.  Such a vision would require intentional in-reach such as periodic pastoral care canvasing to all members (more often than stewardship canvasing for sure!) to uncover those in isolation, small group membership as the fundamental nucleus of Christian Community and an expectation of all members, and the employment of technology for tracking pastoral needs and broadcasting pastoral/personal announcements and actionable connections that goes way beyond a mention in the prayers of the people. 
Too often I am asked, “Is there something going on with Brenda? I thought I heard her name mentioned in the prayers of the people and now that I think about it, I haven’t seen her lately.”  In the clergy-centric model, the clergy is the conduit for all pastoral needs communication often through the official channels of the church such as the prayers of the people which are almost a tease.  (Can you imagine getting an email from your father to pray for your mother’s illness and nothing else?)  Brenda would have made her upcoming surgery known because seeing herself as a care giver, she knows the opportunities and understands the importance of receiving care herself.  Going it alone is not how she understand life in Christian Community.  Brenda’s need for help is then made know through pastoral connections newsletters, prayers would have been solicited, her small group would be responding, the hospital where she is recovering made known, and a “Caring Bridge”[1] set up and linked so parishioners could know exactly what is going on and how Brenda would like them to respond.  The goal being a church community where pastoral care is named as a fundamental value, where vulnerability is celebrated and care-giving understood to be a non-optional responsibility of all members and empowered through relationship and technology. 
C. Lay Administered Pastoral Care Plans are the Norm
Each parishioner experiencing a pastoral need, should have a pastoral care plan developed to guide the community’s response.  While many congregations already do such plans, I would suggest that the structure for developing them is probably untenable if were to be extended to the church I am describing that aspires to care for the other 80%.  This is because most of our pastoral care plans are again, clergy-centric and driven by the needs of “insiders” and so the pool is kept small.  If we were to expand that reach deeply into the community of those formerly “outsiders,” we will likely need to rethink how we structure such plans.  They will need to be lay developed, lay supervised and lay administered.  Clergy, will need to step back from their roles as care givers, and become mentors and coaches for lay care givers. 
In the example of Brenda.  When she made her surgery known to the church, a member, possibly a member of her small group ideally, would be the point person for developing a pastoral care plan (including being the go to person for questions, setting up a visit schedule and needs list through a “caring bridge” and so on).  This would continue after her return from the hospital and a long-term plan is put into place depending on her needs.  Ride sharing, occasional clergy check-ins, meals, monitoring of her progress and so on would be administered through her point person empowered through technology.  If Brenda isn’t part of a small group or if she is not getting the kind of ongoing support needed, the point person would assign a Stephen Minister (or similar) to be with Brenda during the ensuing months – perhaps becoming that point person for additional care giving if needed.    
D. Clergy Role Shifts to Teacher/Mentor
So what is the role then for clergy in this model?  As I alluded to above, it needs to shift to the roles of teacher, mentor and administrator of lay care givers and away from the role of primary care provider.  In Part One of this essay, I mentioned that I think of the church as a “Discipleship Academy” that is, we should see ourselves as a seminary that actively graduates followers of Christ into the world to love and serve it and in the process, make more disciples.  As such, our academy needs teachers and mentors who gauge success not on the number of people they visited, but by the number of care givers they graduated and the number of people they have visited.      
E.  Extending Pastoral Care to the Neighborhood
Finally, if the scorecard for clergy needs to shift from caring for parishioners to forming care givers, we need to create a scorecord for this new army of pastoral care providers.  I would propose here that a page be taken from the missional church and that along with the training in pastoral care, we cast a vision for our membership to begin seeing their neighborhood, the very block on which they live, as their mission field and their home as the mission center.  Just as the church as a pastoral care plan for its members, might our members have a pastoral care plan for their neighbors?  Just as we might use technology to develop and empower networks of parishioners with needs might we do that on our own block?  I have experienced this in our own neighborhood where we have mobilized neighbors to pull together to care for one of our own.  We have developed with some a tool and garden equipment borrowing network and ‘open door’ policies with our sheds so I can borrow a hedge trimmer or lawn mower when we need it and none of us has to own all of it.  Could a neighborhood prayer list be far behind? 
Of course, such relationship don’t start there.  We had to build up to it beginning with breaking the ice over dinner invitations, then joint parties, joint garage sales and so on.  If we are to be kingdom builders, we need to start with being community makers in our own backyards and extending pastoral care is an important part of that.  In time, we might even begin to think of our small groups less as church groups and more as neighborhood groups. 
IV.  Conclusion
While not a comprehensive solution, this essay seeks to inspire our imagination about how we might reimagine the how and why of pastoral care and its possible role in the larger emerging church conversation in which we are engaged.  An important component of this, which is implied, is that any congregation seeking such a culture shift, would also have to implement as systematic theology of gift discernment and the ministry of all believers.  While it is a concept we certainly talk about and aspire to, we undermine it as soon as we step into church where the priest is responsible for the exclusive production and execution of 90% of what goes on, including writing and even delivering the “prayers of the people.”  If praying shapes believing, then worship forms our discipleship.  Just as we must continue to reform and open up our worship, that spirit must extend to the sacred cow of pastoral care.  By empowering our membership with the full compliment of the skills and aspirations of a disciple, we will begin to shift the culture from a customer/member mentality to a missionary mind.  And only then, will we begin to unlock the promise of the missional church within us.  



[1] Websites such as http://www.caringbridge.org, if employed and deployed to the congregation in systematics ways, have the capacity to revolutionize pastoral care and community connection.  Private Facebook groups are also a possibly opportunity that is underutilized – particularly for smaller congregations – as social media adoption continues to grow. 

No comments: